Here's where the controversy starts: SDS (San Diego Studio) now hands out BR reward cards later in the season through Rewind Packs, and these packs are sellable. That means cards once deemed rare and exclusive can flood the market later, diminishing their long-term value.

Still, there's a window of MLB 25 Stubs time where these BR-exclusive cards are among the most valuable on the market. If you earn them early, especially Flawless-level cards, you can flip them for a serious return before they become widely accessible.

Look For Meta Swings and Hidden Gems

Some low-rated cards perform well beyond their attributes. These are often called "budget beasts", cards that, thanks to swing mechanics or specific attribute distributions, punch well above their weight.

Take 79 OVR Jason Giambi, for example. Despite his Silver rating, he has a powerful, smooth swing that plays incredibly well in BR. The same goes for players like Adam Dunn or Live Series Giancarlo Stanton. They may lack versatility or defensive prowess, but in a short game, their power and swing timing can change everything.

When in doubt, draft for power over contact, and look for hitters with proven swings. One homer can be the difference between a win and a loss in BR.

Burn Your Common Pick On a Starter

Every BR draft includes one Common-rated player. The best way to handle this is to use that pick on a fifth starting pitcher, ideally someone you can completely avoid using. This frees up bullpen and lineup spots for stronger players.

Why does this work? Because your primary starter will regain stamina every few games, letting you recycle your ace without ever needing that fifth guy. If you've already filled out your rotation with solid arms, you can alternatively use the Common pick on buy MLB The Show 25 Stubs a pinch runner or emergency reliever.